Impression | ‘Meatspace’? Know-how Does Funny Issues to Language

To rejoice April Fools’ Working day I’ve tried using to have some entertaining in this e-newsletter, which include in the option of reader mail and the quotation of the working day. Everything’s accurate, nevertheless — no fooling.

I’m fascinated by what the evolution of language tells us about financial growth in excess of the decades. In concentrating on language I’m spending homage to my incisive Viewpoint colleague John McWhorter as very well as the wonderful William Safire, who for a long time wrote the “On Language” column in The New York Moments Journal. The variance is I’ll attempt to keep connected to my most important subject matter, economics.

Think about this coinage: meatspace. It refers merely to the bodily world, where by we have tangible bodies built of … meat. “Meatspace” is a word that didn’t have to have to exist right until the creation of cyberspace. Technological progress provides us a new perspective on things we the moment took for granted, in this situation truth by itself.

“I.C.E. vehicle” (pronounced “ice”) is comparable. I.C.E. is quick for inside combustion engine, a modifier that was superfluous right up until electrical vehicles came on the scene. Like meatspace, it is what the journalist Frank Mankiewicz identified as a “retronym” — a new time period that is invented for a thing outdated because the first expression has grow to be ambiguous, ordinarily since of some development these as a technological progress.

There are tons of lists of retronyms on the web. Amongst my favorites, just about every revealing society’s progress in some way or a further: incandescent light-weight bulb (necessitated by fluorescent, LED, etcetera.) landline cellular phone analog enjoy Euclidean geometry difficult copy vacuum tube radio (as opposed to transistor radio — although who bothers specifying “transistor” radio any more?).

Not like retronyms, “infrastructure” is an aged term that keeps having asked to do more operate. It commenced as a time period from French railroad engineering referring to the layers of substance that go beneath (“infra”) the tracks. Its that means expanded to include roads, bridges, sewers and energy strains, and extremely not long ago expanded again to include people today, exclusively caregivers, as in this actuality sheet from the Biden White House very last 12 months, which stated, “The president’s prepare will make sizeable investments in the infrastructure of our treatment economic climate, starting up by generating new and much better employment for caregiving personnel.”

Our language preserves aged techniques of dwelling as definitely as amber preserves very long-lifeless insects or volcanic ash preserved historical Pompeii. We however “cc:” people on emails even however progressively few of us have at any time created carbon copies on a typewriter (I have). We “copy and paste” text, scarcely conscious that precise aromatic paste made use of to be included. I not long ago discovered that uppercase and lowercase letters got their names from true picket circumstances of lead that have been used by compositors for printing. Folks continue to converse about “dialing” mobile phone quantities even though phones never have dials, and “rolling up” vehicle windows even although hand cranks are very long absent.

Alongside those people strains, it’s amazing that perfectly into the 21st century we’re even now describing the toughness of our cars and trucks and vans in comparison to the electric power of horses. That utilization traces back again to James Watt, the Scottish inventor who produced a better steam engine in the late 18th century and as opposed it to a horse, because in all those days horses and pulleys were being made use of to elevate buckets of drinking water out of flooded coal mines.

Engineering has leapt in advance due to the fact the 18th century but the English language has not, at the very least when it will come to describing the electrical power of engines. Just one horsepower, by the way, equals 746 watts — and sure, watt is named immediately after James Watt.

Not all complex terminology has horsepower’s keeping energy. In economics, for instance, “priming the pump” employed to be a effectively-comprehended phrase for what currently we call stimulus. A conventional pump will not work if there is air in the pump or the line to it. You have to pour drinking water into it — to “prime” it — right before you can get drinking water out. In an era when people ended up a lot more familiar with pumps, it produced sense to them that the federal government would occasionally will need to pour some cash into the financial state to get it doing work and pump substantially additional money out. That metaphor is fewer intuitively persuasive these days.

Flat-display, higher-definition shade TVs are just TVs currently. Ballpoint pens are just pens. And right before extensive, self-driving electric powered automobiles will be just cars. Time and know-how march on.


In examining your March 25 publication on the economist Clifford Winston, a believer in no cost marketplaces, I considered of this aged joke: An engineer and an economist are trapped in a deep gap in the ground. Right after quite a few several hours the engineer suggests, “I just can not determine out a way to get us out of right here.” The economist turns to him and says, “It’s easy! Very first, think a ladder….”

Allan Kemp

Littleton, Colo.


“Asking me now to produce on how I come to feel about economics journals is like asking a lamppost to create a memoir on canine.”

— Philip Mirowski, “The Effortless Overall economy of Science?” (2004)

Have feed-back? Send out a take note to [email protected]